AgEcon Search

AgEcon Search >
       University of Western Australia, Agricultural and Resource Economics >
          Working Papers >

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://purl.umn.edu/200176

Title: Reviewing journal papers effectively, efficiently and fairly
Authors: Pannell, David J.
Authors (Email): Pannell, David (david.pannell@uwa.edu.au)
Keywords: publication
research
refereeing
JEL Codes: A10
B40
Issue Date: 2015-03-22
Series/Report no.: Working Paper
1501
Abstract: Academic journals rely on researchers agreeing to act as reviewers (or referees) for submitted papers. Researchers who publish papers themselves benefit from the contributions of those who review their papers, and so have a moral obligation to provide reviewing services for journals. However, reviewing is time consuming, and the total number of papers published continues to increase, so editors have found it increasingly difficult to obtain reviews. Further, the quality of reviews provided by reviewers varies greatly. This paper addresses various issues related to the journal refereeing process, including: tips on how to go about conducting a high-quality review efficiently and fairly; what can and cannot realistically be expected of referees; advice on dealing with ethical issues in refereeing; problems with the existing peer-review system used most commonly by journals; and a look at novel review systems.
Notes: Paper presented at the 59th Conference of the Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society (AARES), Rotorua, 10-13 February 2015
URI: http://purl.umn.edu/200176
Institution/Association: University of Western Australia, School of Agricultural and Resource Economics>Working Papers
Total Pages: 13
Collections:Working Papers

Files in This Item:

File Description SizeFormat
SARE_WP1501_Reviewing papers David Pannell.pdfWP1501 Pannell136KbPDFView/Open
Recommend this item

All items in AgEcon Search are protected by copyright.

 

 

Brought to you by the University of Minnesota Department of Applied Economics and the University of Minnesota Libraries with cooperation from the Agricultural and Applied Economics Association.

All papers are in Acrobat (.pdf) format. Get Adobe Reader

Contact Us

Powered by: